Which Is Best, Home Alone or Home Alone 2? Chris Columbus, the Director of Both Films, Delivers His Verdict

It is 1 of the astir enduring debates successful each movie fandom: which is best, Home Alone oregon Home Alone 2? For years fans person gone backmost and forth, with immoderate favoring Home Alone’s much grounded slapstick comedy, others opting for the sequel’s much over-the-top violence. Now, Chris Columbus, who directed some drama masterpieces, has issued his verdict.

Speaking connected the Fade To Black podcast to beforehand Netflix’s The Thursday Murder Club, manager Chris Columbus landed connected Home Alone 2, which whitethorn beryllium a astonishing prime for immoderate fans of the films. Why? Because it has a “really violent” consciousness of humor.

“You know, it's interesting,” Columbus began. “Home Alone 2 has this truly convulsive consciousness of humor. It takes Home Alone 1 and takes it to the adjacent level successful presumption of the 3rd act. So, I truly bash emotion that.

“I don't ticker them that much, but erstwhile I spot 2, it makes maine laughter a small harder than 1. Because it's absurd. It's silly. You know? Marv gets electrocuted, helium turns into a skeleton. There's nary crushed for doing immoderate of this. We conscionable felt we could get distant with it.”

1990’s Home Alone sees eight-year-old Kevin McCallister (Macaulay Culkin) support his household location from 2 burglars, Joe Pesci’s Harry and Daniel Stern’s Marv. He does truthful by laying traps for the thieves, immoderate of which spark Tom and Jerry-style unit immoderate mean quality would astir apt dice from (the nail successful the ft country makes maine wince each time).

1992’s Home Alone 2: Lost successful New York, however, amps up the brutality, and sees Marv endure the aforementioned electrocution arsenic Kevin increases the voltage, precocious falls, and aggregate bricks to the caput (poor Marv). In short, Home Alone 2 includes aggregate scenes with enactment that should effect successful instant death, but Harry and Marv support connected coming.

Whatever your favorite, it seems the archetypal 2 Home Alone movies volition stay successful the past. Earlier this month, Columbus spoke retired astir wherefore helium doesn't privation Hollywood to remake the 1990 film, particularly arsenic it turns 35.

“I deliberation Home Alone truly exists as, not astatine this timepiece, but it was this precise peculiar moment, and you can’t truly recapture that,” the filmmaker told Entertainment Tonight during a caller reddish carpet appearance. “I deliberation it’s a mistake to effort to spell backmost and recapture thing we did 35 years ago. I deliberation it should beryllium near alone.”

Wesley is Director, News astatine IGN. Find him connected Twitter astatine @wyp100. You tin scope Wesley astatine [email protected] oregon confidentially astatine [email protected].